Conneaut Pizza & Sub Shop Menu (Update 2025)

  1. Home
  2. Menu

Welcome to Conneaut Pizza & Sub Shop, a beloved establishment nestled at 223 Broad St in Conneaut, OH. This cozy eatery has been serving up culinary delights for over 40 years, renowned for its signature stromboli, which patrons describe as the best they've ever had. Each dish is crafted with care, ensuring generous portions and rich flavors that make it a top choice for locals and visitors alike.

But it doesn’t stop there; the menu also features scrumptious pizzas and subs, along with crispy wings and hearty spaghetti dinners. The reviews speak for themselves—customers rave about the friendly service, fast delivery, and the unforgettable taste that keeps them returning. Whether you're dining in or grabbing takeout, Conneaut Pizza & Sub Shop promises an exceptional experience filled with comfort food that truly satisfies.
Dinner
Soups
12 inch subs
Appetizer
Sides
Baskets
Stromboli
salads
Pizza
bone in wings
combo meals

Dinner

4PC fried chicken dinner

4 PC fried chicken roll potatoes and side
US$15.80

Small Chicken Parmesan

Pasta sauce and chicken patty on top of a bed of spaghetti with provolone cheese
US$11.35

Large chicken parmesan dinner

2 PC chicken resting on top of pasta noodles with provolone cheese pasta sauce and mozzarella cheese on top garlic bread and either a salad or dessert we have chocolate pie cheese cake
US$14.05

Chicken tenders dinner

4 tenders your choice of potatoes and side comes with a dipping sauce for tenders
US$13.75

Large spaghetti dinner

10 oz of pasta noodles 1 of our homemade meatballs pasta sauce garlic bread your choice of salad, apple sauce or dessert
US$10.50

Small spaghetti Dinner Salad

8oz pasta noodles 1 of our homemade meatballs garlic bread your choice of salad, applesauce or dessert
US$8.00

Popcorn chicken Dinner Salad

8oz of breaded popcorn chicken your choice of potatoes and side and dinner roll with butter
US$13.75

Lasagna dinner

Piece of our homemade lasagna garlic bread your choice of salad, applesauce or dessert
US$13.65

Honey Biscuit Shrimp dinner

7 oz breaded deep fried shrimp served with cocktail sauce your choice of potatoes and side
US$13.75

1 pc yeuling battered haddock fillet dinner

1 pc fish choice of potato,side and roll
US$13.75

Broccoli and cheese

12 oz chef Pierre broccoli and cheese soup and crackers
US$4.75

Stuffed pepper soup

12 oz stuffed pepper seasoned ground beef, green bell peppers, white rice,ripe tomatoes, savory sweet tomato broth
US$4.75

Italian Wedding Soups

12oz Italian wedding soup a unique blend of Italian style meatballs simmered in a light chicken broth with acini did pepe pasta, fresh spinach,onions and tender carrots
US$4.75

Chili

12 oz bowl of our homemade chili
US$4.85

Soups

12 inch subs

Chicken cordon Bleu

1 of our breaded chicken patties 2 rolled PCs of Smithfield Virginia brand honey cured ham 3 provolone cheese on top
US$9.20

Italian sub

12 inch sub bun lettuce, tomato 2 salami,row of pepperoni 3 salami,3 provolone on top
US$9.20

Chicken parmesan Sub

12 inch sub bun breaded chicken patty pasta sauce and provolone cheese
US$9.20

Super sub

12 inch sub bun lettuce, tomato,3 salami,2 pcs Smithfield ham 3 provolone cheese on top
US$9.20

bbq ham

lettuce,tomato,4pcs of rooled ham bbq sauce 3 provolone cheese
US$9.20

ham sub

lettuce,tomato 4 pcs of rolled ham 3 provolone cheese
US$9.20

veggie sub

lettuce,tomato,mushroom,onion,green pepper,black olives 3 provolone cheese
US$9.20

pepperoni sub

lettuce,tomato,2 rows of pepperoni 3 provolone cheese
US$9.20

steak sub

lettuce,tomato,4 pcs of steakum 3 provolone cheese
US$9.20

philly steak sub

12 inch sub roll ,lettuce ,tomato,steak,green peppers,mushrooms,onion,american cheese
US$9.90

buffalo chicken sub

12 inch sub bun lettuce tomato spicey fajati chicken buffalo sauce provolone cheese
US$9.20

meatball sub

12 inch sub bun homemade meatballs provolone cheese
US$9.20

Pizza Sub

12 inch sub bun row of pepperoni pizza sauce 2 nd row of pepperoni pizza sauce provolone cheese
US$9.20

spicey chicken fajati

12 inch sub bun lettuce tomato spicey fajati chicken provolone cheese
US$9.20

sausage sub

12 inch sub bun 2 pcs of sausage pasta sauce provolone cheese
US$9.20

yueling battered haddock fillet Sub

12 inch sub bun lettuce tomato 1 pc haddock fillet provolone cheese
US$9.20

stromboli sub

3 layers of cheese and pizza item 1 pizza item free side of pizza sauce for dipping
US$9.20

Cheese Sub

12 inch sub bun lettuce and tomato ,4 rolled pcs of provolone cheese and cheese on top
US$9.20

honey biscuit shrimp sub

3 oz honey biscuit shrimp ,pickels and provolone cheese
US$9.20

Cheese sticks

6 breaded cheese sticks with dipping sauce
US$7.25

Deep fried mushrooms

5 oz of breaded fried mushrooms
US$5.90

Cheddar jalapeno poppers

6 jalapeno poppers
US$7.25

onion rings

6 oz battered onion rings
US$3.50

Cheesy Pullapart Flatbread

9 pcs pullapart with 2 dip sauces
US$7.00

Appetizer

Sides

Bosco sticks

3 cheese filled bread sticks with dipping sauce
US$5.30

Pepperoni balls

3 pepperoni balls with cheese no sauce
US$5.65

Popcorn Chicken

8 oz of deep fried chicken and choice of dipping sauce
US$6.95

fries

8 oz frech fries salt and ketchup
US$2.75

jojo Fries

8 oz jojo fries salt and ketchup
US$4.45

Curly Fries

8 oz curly fries salt and ketchup
US$3.15

Onion Rings

6 oz breaded onion rings
US$3.50

Shrimp

side order of breaded shrimp 2 cocktail sauce
US$6.90

4 pc chicken tenders

4 breaded chicken tenders with dip sauce
US$7.30

Mashed Potatoes and Gravy

12 oz cup idaho mashed potatoes and chicken gravy
US$3.95

Garlic Bread with Cheese

1/2 12 inch sub bun butter garlic and mozzarella cheese
US$2.10

Double cheeseburger basket

2 holten 1/4 lb patties bun 2 slices American cheese your choice of fries,Jojo fries,curly fries,onion rings .60 cents more for mashed potato and gravy (optional items for burger lettuce, tomato, onion or pickles
US$9.25

Double hamburger basket

2 1/4 lb holten beef patties,bun your choice of fries,Jojo fries,curly fries,onion rings optional mashed potatoes and gravy 60 cents more, optional items for burgers lettuce, tomato, onion,pickle
US$9.25

Mini stromboli

4 slice personal stromboli comes with cheese 60 cents each additional items,choices are pepperoni,ham, salami, mushrooms, banana peppers, sausage, green peppers,onion,black olives,steak, tomato, meatballs,bacon
US$3.60

3 pc chicken tender basket

3 pcs of breaded chicken tenders and choice of dip sauce and fries
US$9.25

popcorn Chicken Basket

6 oz breaded popcorn chicken choice of 6 oz fries and dip sauce
US$9.25

chicken sandwich basket

breaded chicken patty on a kaiser roll choice of fries
US$9.25

cheeseburger basket

holten beef patty on a kaiser roll with cheese choice of fries
US$7.80

hamburger basket

holten beef patty on a kaiser roll with choice of fries
US$7.80

Baskets

Stromboli

Small stromboli

8 slice comes with cheese 1.30 per item item choice pepperoni, mushroom, banana peppers,sausage,green peppers, Onion,black olives,ham, salami, meatballs,steak,breaded chicken patty,fajati chicken, tomato,bacon
US$8.60

large meatlovers

pepperoni,sausage,ham,meatball,chicken,bacon
US$26.60

Large 12 slice Stromboli

just cheese 1.70 per item
US$13.25

French Bread Pizza

just cheese .60 cents per item
US$4.00

large tossed

lettuce tomato green pepper onions black olives peppericinnis
US$6.20

salads

Pizza

sheet pizza

30 pc party pizza with cheese 3.60 per item
US$25.65

16 inch Large Pizza

12 slice large pizza with cheese 1.70 per item
US$14.35

mini Personal Pizza

4 slice mini pizza with cheese .60 per item
US$4.00

8 slice medium pizza

with cheese 1.70 per item
US$12.00

medium stuffed crust Pizza

medium pizza crust stuffed with mozzarella cheese 4 mini cups of pizza sauce to dip crust in 1.70 per item
US$14.40

large Works Pizza

16 inch 12 slice pepperoni,xcheese,ham,banana peppers,sausage,green peppers,onion,black olives,meatball
US$27.15

kansas city bbq
US$1.30

garlic parm wings

butter and garlic with parmensan cheese
US$1.30

dry ranch
US$1.30

zesty parm. wings

zesty parmesan sauce
US$1.30

mild Wings

bone in mild wings
US$1.30

bone in wings

combo meals

Double Cheeseburger Combo

2 angus patties on a kaiser roll american cheese fries and 16.9 soda add 50 cents for jojo fries,curly fries or onion rings
US$12.10

double hamburger combo

2 angus patties on a kaiser roll 8 oz fries 16.9 soda add 50 cents for jojo,curly fries or onion rings
US$12.10

Cheeseburger Combo

cheese burger 8 oz fries 16.9 soda add 50 cents jojo,curly fries or onion rings
US$10.45

hamburger combo

hamburger 8 oz fries 16.9 soda add 50 cents for jojo,curly fries or onion rings
US$10.45

chicken tender combo

4 breaded tenders,8oz fries ,16.9 soda add 50 cents for jojo,curly fries or onion ringd
US$12.10

shrimp combo

8 oz breaded shrimp,8 oz fries,16.9 soda add 50 cents for jojo,curly fries,or onion rings
US$10.45

yueling battered haddock fillet sub

1 haddock fillet on a 7 inch bun 8 oz fries and drink add 50 cents for jojo,curly fries or onion rings
US$12.10

Sloppy Joe Combo Sandwich

homemade sloppy joe choice of fries and drink
US$10.45

6 inch sub combo

choice of sub ,fries and drink 50 cents xtra for jojo,curly fries or orings
US$10.00